Eddie Boyle and The Night Drop Crew
The Irishman Who Headed The Gambino Crime Family’s Robbery Gang
Written By Andrew J Nolan
No Irish Need Apply? Two of America’s oldest ethnic tribes may not have always seen eye to eye down through the years, but it has to be said, the Italians sure do have an eye for an enterprising Irishman in their ranks. Or indeed, an Irish woman. Al Capone, after all, married a well-educated, middle-class Brooklyn colleen by the name of Mae Coughlin, whose parents had immigrated to the US from Ireland during the 1890s. On the other hand, it was the Irish ‘White Hand Gang’ that forced Capone, Mae and their young son to leave Brooklyn after the deadly outfit placed the young criminal upstart Alphonse on their hitlist. Jimmy Burke, played by Robert De Niro in Martin Scorsese’s Goodfellas, was the mastermind behind the 1978 Lufthansa Heist where $5.875 million was stolen from New York’s JFK airport. ‘The Big Irishman’ Burke was a feared and trusted associate of the Lucchese crime family and enlisted fellow Irishmen Henry Hill, Robert ‘Frenchy’ McMahon and his own son Frank Burke, among others, to carry out at the time the largest cash robbery in American history. And then of course there was Frank Sheeran, again played by De Niro in Scorsese’s The Irishman, an epic gangster saga depicting the life of the Bufalino crime family hitman whose many jobs included the alleged murder of labour union leader, Jimmy Hoffa.
Following this well-trodden, unruly path was Edmund ‘Eddie’ Boyle, a South Brooklyn native who would quickly attract the attention of the notorious Gambino crime family, who in turn appointed him leader of their formidable robbery gang The Night Drop Crew. The neighbourhoods of Bay Ridge, Sunset Park and Bensonhurst in Brooklyn’s southwest corner were traditional breeding grounds for juvenile Irish and Italian criminals intent on becoming the underworld’s next big thing, and Boyle was no exception. Eddie Boyle’s criminal career began as a car thief providing getaway vehicles for armed robberies organised by Gambino Family soldier Thomas ‘Huck’ Carbonaro. During the 1990s, ‘Irish Eddie’ was believed to be the ringleader of a crew that stole more than $900,000 from National Westminster Bank on Fifth Avenue in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, while carrying out at least ten other bank and home robberies netting the gang nearly $2 million in total. The Night Drop Crew typically sought out banks situated in financial districts all around the US, with the east coast and Las Vegas being their favourite haunts. After punching out the night deposit boxes to gain initial access and under the cover of darkness, the guileful gang carried specialised tools in order to grab the bags of cash deposited by businesses over long weekends.
By this point, the cops now referred to the gang as ‘The Boyle Crew’ in reference to the adept Irishman who headed up a revolving door of Gambino Family foot soldiers eager to nab vast sums of easy money. One such Boyle Crew member was Chris Paciello, who progressed from bank robbery to becoming the King of Miami Nightlife, and whose clubs attracted supermodels and superstars like Madonna, whom he went on to date. In 2000, Paciello was sentenced to a mere seven years in prison for taking part in a 1992 robbery of Chemical Bank in Staten Island, and a 1993 botched break-in which led to the death of one of the home residents, Judith Shemtov. More on that later.
In late 1997, Boyle and members of the gang, Carbonaro, John Matera, Thomas Dono and Letterio Decarlo began to suspect that Frank Hydell, a bit player on the periphery of the Gambino family, was cooperating with the Government. It was believed that Hydell gave information to the FBI relating to between 10 and 20 crimes committed by The Boyle Crew, as well as information regarding a heist that had been planned to take place in New Jersey, where some of the gang would be caught in the act. What worried the gang most of all though was the prospect of Hydell telling the cops about the murder of Frank Parasole at a Brooklyn social club on Super Bowl Sunday in 1997. Parasole supposedly forced one of Boyle’s friends to do construction labour on what had initially been agreed to be a no-show job. Eddie’s pal felt disrespected, so the Boyle Crew allegedly killed Parasole.
Frank Hydell, as it happened, had a brother James who disappeared in October 1986 after being abducted by infamous Mafia Cops Stephen Caracappa and Louis Eppolito. The pair of corrupt NYPD detectives delivered James Hydell to Lucchese Underboss Anthony ‘Gaspipe’ Casso, who believing James had tried to assassinate him, tortured and killed Hydell in an act of revenge. The Hydell name certainly wasn’t a popular one within mafia circles and ‘Huck’ Carbonaro began to plot Frank’s murder. On the night of April 27 1998, Matera, a close friend of Frank’s, lured him to Scarlett’s strip joint on Staten Island and while leaving the club in the wee small hours, Hydell was shot dead at close range in front of his car. All the evidence suggested that Carbonaro was the getaway driver and Eddie Boyle was the shooter who blasted Frank Hydell three times. The FBI also believed that Matera’s nephews, Dono and Decarlo, were present at the scene of the murder.
Between 1986 through to 1999, Boyle had eased through a life of crime with only five relatively minor convictions, serving a total of two years in jail. However, in September 2003, Eddie, aged 39, was arrested and indicted as a ‘principal organiser’ of The Night Drop Crew where prosecutors claimed that from 1993 to 2002, he took part in one robbery, five burglaries and four failed bank jobs. The 33-count racketeering indictment detailed how Boyle, with the help of lookouts and getaway drivers, successfully led his crew to the 1994 $900,000 heist of the National Westminster Bank in Bay Ridge where they entered the vault through an adjoining boiler room and overpowered two guards. At a detention hearing, assistant U.S. attorney Joseph Lipton then alleged that on the stroke of midnight on April 28, 1998, Boyle was the gunman who shot Frank Hydell to death outside Scarlett’s Strip Club. The prosecutor insisted Eddie Boyle was a danger to society who should be jailed while awaiting trial. Brooklyn Federal Judge Sterling Johnson disagreed, ruling that strict home detention and a $2.5 million bond secured by properties belonging to Boyle’s mother, sister, and two friends would suffice.
Nevertheless, Boyle’s bail was revoked when Lipton informed Judge Johnson that the lawyer Richard Rehbock, an attorney for Boyle’s co-defendant Thomas Dono, had boasted to John A. Gotti Junior in a tape recorded jailhouse discussion that Boyle had been helping his own cause through some very dubious activities. In a taped segment played for Johnson, Rehbock was heard telling Gotti: ‘(Boyle) calls up the state of Florida and gets motor vehicle records while posing as ‘an investigator for an insurance company,’ adding, ‘I told him. “You beat this case; I’ll hire you to work on (Junior’s) case.” Soon after the proceeding, Thomas Dono fired Rehbock and hired a new attorney.
As if going to prison because of the bluster and bragging from Dono’s lawyer wasn’t bad enough, Boyle then lost the services of his own lawyer, Martin Geduldig, when he claimed that he’d run out of money to pay him. As a result, Lipton asked Johnson to forfeit the properties of Boyle’s family and friends to the government, but luckily for the Boyle clan, Judge Sterling refused while Boyle found himself a new attorney.
‘Irish’ Eddie Boyle was eventually convicted in 2005 at the United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York for racketeering, conspiracy to commit bank burglary, and nine counts of bank burglary and attempted bank burglary. Chris Paciello, Madonna’s ex-boyfriend, stood in the witness stand for two days as a cooperating witness for prosecutors against Boyle, where he stated that himself and Edmund Boyle were part of the crew that made off with almost $1 million in the 1994 bank robbery in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn. Paciello, it turned out, had been cooperating with prosecutors since 2000 in order to get his sentence reduced for the killing of Mrs Shemtov and various other crimes he admitted. He could have faced more than 30 years in prison, but instead was released in 2006. The jury in Brooklyn federal court found Eddie Boyle guilty of 11 of the 12 counts and he was sentenced to 151 months’ imprisonment. Boyle was acquitted of actually killing of Frank Hydell in the parking lot of Scarlett’s Strip Club.
Thomas Carbonaro was sentenced to 70 years in prison for conspiring to murder Frank Hydell and other crimes, while John Matera pled guilty to charges including conspiracy to murder Hydell, and received a sentence of 20 years in prison. Boyle appealed the conviction on the racketeering charge, arguing that Judge Johnson had improperly instructed the jury on the definition of an ‘enterprise’ as defined in the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act (RICO). The United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit denied the appeal in 2007, prompting Boyle to appeal to the Supreme Court which in turn granted a judicial review of the decision in 2008.
Boyle stood trial again in February 2010, where U.S. District Judge Colleen McMahon acquitted him of the substantive charges of murder in aid of racketeering and witness tampering. At sentencing, Judge McMahon stated that the evidence demonstrated by a preponderance of the evidence that Boyle murdered Frank Hydell. However, McMahon explained that the court would not ignore the jury’s verdict acquitting Boyle of the substantive murder charges and limited the sentence imposed to 20 years’ imprisonment. Letterio Decarlo and Thomas Dono were convicted then in March 2010 for their participation in the conspiracy that resulted in Hydell’s murder, and each was sentenced to 180 months in prison.

‘The Lord of Brooklyn’ Shamus Connolly, actor Joe Donofrio (Goodfellas, A Bronx Tale), my son and myself outside Kelly’s Tavern, Bay Ridge in 2024
In an October 2010 Decision and Order case, Eddie Boyle, now 46, sat stone-faced as Judge McMahon blasted him as a ‘heinous and unrepentant career criminal…who needed to be locked up until he’s old and grey. I believe that if he is released anytime soon, he is committed to returning to his life of crime.’ McMahon also stated that Boyle would have become a fully-fledged member of La Cosa Nostra but for its ‘blatant ethnic discrimination,’ noting pointedly that ‘no Irish need apply.’ The Judge concluded that ‘Eddie Boyle was up to his eyeballs in the affairs of the Gambino Crime Family’, he was ‘the right-hand man of the notorious Gambino soldier Thomas “Huck” Carbonaro’ and that ‘Boyle engaged in and/or was privy to an array of criminal activities, including murder, extortion, gambling, loansharking, and theft. Indeed, the evidence proved that Boyle personally committed more than two racketeering acts, including gambling, extortion, auto thefts and interstate transportation of stolen property.’
Sure enough on November 10, 2010, in Manhattan Federal Court, Eddie Boyle was convicted of racketeering crimes in connection with his participation in the Gambino Organized Crime Family, including murder, witness tampering, extortion, and various property crimes and sentenced to a further 20 years in prison by Judge McMahon.
There’s no doubt that Boyle would’ve been given ample opportunity by law enforcement to rat out his Gambino Family associates, but just like The No Name Crew in Boston, ‘Irish’ Eddie stood firm sticking to his old school criminal codes of conduct. Detectives involved in the case described him as ‘intelligent, cool under pressure and most importantly, a stand up guy.’ Within the Gambino Crime Family he was respected as a clever, capable, resourceful money maker who wouldn’t buckle under pressure. Boyle is currently serving his 20 year sentence in Fort Dix Prison, New Jersey and is scheduled for release in 2030. Several sentence reduction requests from his lawyers have thus far been refused, the most recent being in November, 2023. Eddie Boyle will be 66 years old come his release day and the once feared Gambino foot soldier will have had plenty of time to ponder his next move.

‘Irish’ Eddie Boyle in Fort Dix Prison, New Jersey
Sources:
FBI archives
New York Post
Jerry Capeci for ‘Gangland’
Exclusive Mafia YouTube Channel